Business Studies
The case
The financial pathway to green manifests itself as a dichotomous and mutuallyexclusive choice between a hybrid car which entails fossil fuel directly and an allelectric car which doesn’t. This exercise frames the decisionmaking process into a typical mutuallyexclusive capital budgeting analysis. We choose Toyota Prius as the hybrid and the Nissan Leaf as the allelectric car.
In August 2015, a Toyota Prius lists at $26,985 as its manufacturer suggested retail price. The corresponding retail price for the Nissan Leaf lists at $29,010.
The Prius has a cityhighway combined efficiency of 50 miles per gallon. For the basecase analysis, let’s assume a gas price at $3.00 per gallon. This will result in a mileage efficiency of 6 ¢/mile.
The Leaf has an efficiency of 5.4 miles/kWh. For basecase analysis, let’s assume electricity supply at a price of 12 ¢/kWh. This will result in a mileage efficiency of 2.2222 ¢/mile.
For simplicity of analysis, let’s assume the a driver who needs to drive 12,000 miles a year or 1,000 miles a month for work, school, and other transportation needs. Let’s further assume the driver faces an auto loan’s interest rate of 3% per year or .25% per month.
To do: We first perform a basecase analysis using the data provided or assumed so far.
Q1: Calculate the monthly cash flows for purchasing and operating the Prius for 10 years. (10%)
Q2: Calculate the monthly cash flows for purchasing and operating the Leaf for 10 years. (10%)
Q3: From the monthly cash flows in the previous two questions, derive the incremental cash flows of purchasing the more expensive Leaf over the lessexpensive Prius for 10 years. (10%)
Q4: From the incremental cash flows established in Q3 above, find the following capitalbudgeting measures.
i. undiscounted payback in years; (5%)
ii. discounted payback in years; (5%)
iii. net present value, NPV, in $; (10%)
iv. internal rate of return, IRR, in % (10%)
v. profitability index (practitioner’s version) (10%)
vi. modified internal rate of return, MIRR, in %. Use reinvestment rate of 1% per annum or .08333% per month. (10%)
Next, we perform 2variable sensitivity analyses over ranges of plausible values for the two variables by calculating the discount payback which is simply the number of years it entails to breakeven the extra $2,025 upfront payment for the allelectric Nissan Leaf. For the Prius, we choose gas price as the variable for a range of 2.00 $/gallon to 6.00 $/gallon over a 50¢ increment. For the Leaf, we choose three variables, namely the interest rate from 0% to 6% per year, electric supply rate from 8 ¢/kWh to 16 ¢/kWh, and tax credit for buying the electric car from $0 (the basecase analysis above) to $2,000 at $500 increment. Beware of the #NUM! output when applying the Excel’s Data, Whatif Analysis, Data Table mode. They are not spurious output but do have their own significant economic interpretation. Those who need help with the Data Table function in Excel, please refer to the Appendix where a similar numerical example was presented as an illustration.
We expect three output tables as follow:
Gas price, $/gallon
2.00 2.50 3.00 3.50 4.00 4.50 5.00 5.50 6.00
Interest rate, % p.a. 0
1
2
3
4
5
6
Table 1: Discounted payback, in years, of an allelectric Leaf over the hybrid Prius at various gas prices and various auto loan interest rates. (20%)
Gas price, $/gallon
2.00 2.50 3.00 3.50 4.00 4.50 5.00 5.50 6.00
Electricity rate, ¢/kWh 8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
Table 2: Discounted payback, in years, of an allelectric Leaf over the hybrid Prius at various gas prices and various electricity supply charge rates. (20%)
Gas price, $/gallon
2.00 2.50 3.00 3.50 4.00 4.50 5.00 5.50 6.00
Tax credit for electric car, $ 0
500
1500
2000
2025
Table 3: Discounted payback, in years of an allelectric Leaf over the hybrid Prius at various gas prices and various tax credit levels. (20%)
Q5: What does the output #NUM! mean financially in Table 1 if you change the price spread from $2,025 to $4,000? Use numbers to justify your answer.
Now, change the price spread back to $2,025 before answer the following questions.
Q6: From Table 1, make two ceteris paribus statements on the discounted payback on each variable. Then, make another combined statement on discounted payback’s trend based on both variables. (20%)
Q7: From Table 2, make two ceteris paribus statements on the discounted payback on each variable. Then, make another combined statement on discounted payback’s trend based on both variables.
(20%)
Q8: From Table 3, make two ceteris paribus statements on the discounted payback on each variable. Then, make another combined statement on discounted payback’s trend based on both variables.
(20%)
Appendix
We illustrate the us
Topquality papers guaranteed
100% original papers
We sell only unique pieces of writing completed according to your demands.
Confidential service
We use security encryption to keep your personal data protected.
Moneyback guarantee
We can give your money back if something goes wrong with your order.
Get free features with our reliable essay writing service

Title page
We offer you a free title page tailored according to the specifics of your particular style.

Custom formatting
Include your preferred formatting style when you order from us to accompany your paper.

Bibliography page
Get a list of references to go with your ordered paper.

24/7 support assistance
Reach out to our support agents anytime for free assistance.
Calculate how much your essay costs
What we are popular for
 English 101
 History
 Business Studies
 Management
 Literature
 Composition
 Psychology
 Philosophy
 Marketing
 Economics